Most of us plan the retirement contributions, the taxes, and the insurance, then wave at giving with “let’s do that later.” Joe Saul-Sehy and OG sit down with Adam Nash, co-founder and CEO of Daffy, and Tim Huebsch, a longtime nonprofit board member and scholarship donor, to flip that script. They talk about why giving ends up last, how to separate “what can I afford?” from “who do I give to?”, and how to find a cause you care about by showing up before you commit. It’s an easy, friendly guide to giving that fits your plan and your life.
What You’ll Walk Away With
- Why giving so often lands at the bottom of the to-do list, and the two hard decisions hiding inside it
- How setting money aside ahead of time can make giving feel easier and more joyful
- A quick game of “check, stock, or donor-advised fund?” for three different kinds of givers
- Why donating appreciated investments can work differently than writing a check, in general terms
- How matching gifts can stretch a donation further
- How to get kids and family involved so giving becomes a shared habit
- What a donor-advised fund through a local community foundation can look like
- How to find your cause by volunteering first, without committing for life
- How to think about joining a nonprofit board, and when to say “not this one”
- Why your time and skills can matter as much as your dollars
Why This Matters Now
The end of the year puts giving front and center, which is exactly when decisions get rushed. Many of us are asked to give and have to answer on the spot, without a plan. That’s stressful for the Confident Explorer who wants to do good without making a costly mistake or feeling judged. This conversation shows how to decide ahead of time, so you can focus on the part that feels good: choosing the causes and people you care about. Remember that this is general education, not tax or financial advice.
From the Basement
Joe Saul-Sehy and OG kick things off with a few jokes about hosting in-laws, and OG shares how he brings giving up with clients. Doug (Joe’s mom’s neighbor) brings Christmas movie trivia and a surprisingly strong opinion about a certain famous lamp. Joe closes with a challenge to every Stacker: don’t just nod along, go do something in your community.
Resources Mentioned
Benjamins After Dark meetup groups, including the Southern Minnesota group Tim helped start: https://stackingbenjamins.com/bad
Daffy, the donor-advised fund platform led by Adam Nash: https://daffy.org
Last year’s Stacking Benjamins conversation with Adam Nash on donor-advised funds: https://www.stackingbenjamins.com/donor-advised-fund-deep-dive-1724



Our Mentor: Adam Nash

Big thanks to Adam Nash for joining us today. To learn more about Adam, visit Daffy – The Donor-Advised Fund for You™ | Give Smarter, Save More.
Doug’s Trivia
- In the 1983 holiday classic A Christmas Story, what was the Christmas gift Ralphie Parker wanted more than anything else?
Have a question for the show?
Want more than just the show notes? How about our newsletter with STACKS of related, deeper links?
- Check out The 201, our email that comes with every Monday and Wednesday episode, PLUS a list of more than 19 of the top money lessons Joe’s learned over his own life about money. From credit to cash reserves, and insurance to investing, we’ll tackle all of these. Head to StackingBenjamins.com/the201 to sign up (it’s free and we will never give away your email to others).
Other Mentions
Join Us Friday!
Tune in on Friday when we explore the connection between great ideas, smart investing, and building a financial game plan that can turn your big ideas into a bigger pile of Benjamins.
Written by: Kevin Bailey
Miss our last show? Listen here: Will Your Plan Survive a Much Longer Life? Five Questions to Ask Before You Retire (SB1924) | Stacking Benjamins
Episode transcript
[00:00:00] opener: Ah, fragile. It must be Italian
[00:00:04] Joe: Well, I think that says fragile, honey.
[00:00:06] opener: Oh, yeah
[00:00:13] Doug: Live from Joe’s mom’s basement, it’s The Stacking Benjamins Show.
[00:00:27] Doug: I’m Joe’s mom’s neighbor, Doug, and here’s a hot take. You don’t get much without giving. And today, we’re gonna teach you how to give more and how to make it easy. That’s right, it’s the wide world of helping your community with two special guests who’ve been there and know the ropes, so you don’t have to reinvent the wheel.
[00:00:46] Doug: Ropes? Wheels? Oh, man, we’re pulling out all the stops with this intro, aren’t we? And because I’m a huge giver, I’ll continue pulling out the best stop of them all, my trivia question. What little magical item are we focused on today? You’ll have to wait to find out. Delayed gratification for the win, am I right?
[00:01:06] Doug: And now, here come three guys who are ready to help you build a better tomorrow, Joe, OG, and special guest, Tim Hitch.
[00:01:16] Joe: You’re not gonna go, “Hip, hip, hip, hip, hip?”
[00:01:18] Doug: I, I couldn’t, I couldn’t figure out how to do it. There’s a whole lot of letters in there and- … I probably would’ve ended, “Hip, hip, hip, hip, hooray.”
[00:01:26] Joe: Hooray. Hey there, Stackers. Happy Wednesday. Welcome back to the Stacking Benjamins show. I’m Joe Saul-Sehy, and we’re super happy you’re here, and we’re gonna help you become a better giver. Because often, we think of giving as this thing that’s the, kind of the dessert at the end of the meal, right? “Oh, I got all the things I gotta do, and you know what?
[00:01:45] Joe: There’s a little left, so let’s, let’s give.” Well, that’s really for people that know giving know that it can be a much more fundamental part of your life and the life of the community around you. And a guy who we refer to as community on this show is here, Mr. OG. How are you, man?
[00:02:03] OG: Fantastic. Yeah. I’m the community glue.
[00:02:05] OG: Yeah.
[00:02:06] Joe: You are the-
[00:02:06] OG: That’s exactly my job …
[00:02:07] Joe: the, the glue that holds it all together. Wow. Yes. That was a reach. And speaking of glue, your in-laws just left. Have you glued the door shut?
[00:02:15] OG: I took away their garage door opener. They’re like, “What, what is this?” I’m like, “I, uh, I’ll take that.”
[00:02:20] Joe: Yes.
[00:02:20] OG: In fact, we had everybody here for senior night a couple of weeks ago, so, so we had both sets.
[00:02:25] OG: It was, um- It was like, uh- That’s great … it’s like we were the, um, concierge team. It’s like, “Could we have some more towels in the guest suite?” Like, “Oh, yes. We’ll, we’ll send Jeeves up right away.”
[00:02:35] Joe: Right. Right. W- we’ll send them over to cabana B- … with your towels. Yes. Right?
[00:02:39] OG: Uh, could we get the hot tub on? It’s, um, it’s a little chilly.
[00:02:41] OG: Yeah.
[00:02:41] Joe: Yes.
[00:02:42] OG: Yes, ma’am. Right away.
[00:02:43] Joe: Well, we’re super happy, OG, today that we have this gentleman with us because not only is he a guy I’ve gotten to know a little bit over the last year, he also is a gentleman who knows giving inside and out. And what’s interesting, and we’re gonna talk a little bit about his accomplishments, but he began in college receiving scholarships from others, which also by receiving scholarships, now he’s able to see the other side of it.
[00:03:11] Joe: Tim Hipschat’s here with us. How are you, man?
[00:03:13] Tim: I’m doing great. Thank you so much for having me today.
[00:03:15] Joe: And that is a true story, right? Your mom worked at the university and you received scholarships.
[00:03:20] Tim: She worked at the university for 45 years and nine months, all in the same office. I had an amazing experience here, but it was possible because of the scholarships that I got.
[00:03:28] Tim: So I b- benefited greatly from them over the years, and now I get a chance to turn around and give back
[00:03:34] Joe: That is so exciting. And you just retired early from General Mills a year and a half ago?
[00:03:39] Tim: Uh, just over a year ago. Uh, was there for 25 years. Amazing company to work for. Had 19 different roles, and just loved the experience, loved the community that was there.
[00:03:49] Joe: Oh, no, come on, Tim. The NDA has probably worn off a few months ago. You can talk crap about the former employer now. Come on, bring it.
[00:03:56] Doug: That sounded like a pro- preprogrammed response, didn’t it?
[00:03:59] Tim: If I had something bad to say, I would, but it was absolutely amazing. And to have that many different experiences across the same company.
[00:04:06] Tim: I th- I started and, and I thought I’d be there two or three years, and I blinked and it was 25 years later, and it was truly a, a perfect fit for me, especially because of all the things I was able to do in the community while I was also there. They had a, a very big focus on community, and that meant a lot to me.
[00:04:21] Joe: You have been involved not only with Minnesota State University system, but also with the University of Minnesota system. You’ve been involved in the local community of Mankato. OG, when I went to Mankato, and Tim was showing me around, I felt like Mankato wouldn’t be the same without Tim, and Tim wouldn’t be Tim without Mankato.
[00:04:42] Joe: Would you say that’s true, Tim?
[00:04:44] Tim: Well, I love the community that I’m in. One of the things that I started doing right out of undergrad, I started getting involved in the community, both for volunteering and then getting involved with nonprofit boards. What an amazing experience to really understand your community by s- getting out there and serving on a board.
[00:04:59] Tim: You get a chance to think strategically much earlier in your career, and it has been just such an amazing experience for me.
[00:05:05] Joe: What was the first step? Do you remember? So you’re getting scholarships in college. What was the first step of going, “You know what? I don’t want to just receive, I want to give”?
[00:05:14] Tim: First step was as a freshman, the presidential scholarship through Brown Printing. As part of that, I had a chance to meet the president of the university. Fast-forward about six months, I’m in my first year experience course. The president comes to speak to the course, and I had a chance to sit down and talk next to him, and he said, “You know, I love technology.”
[00:05:32] Tim: And he said, “Well, why don’t you get involved with student government?” That was my first thing of, of getting involved and giving back, and that started the, the whole process of, of just being engaged and understanding, okay, how do, what it all takes to make an organization work.
[00:05:45] Joe: We’re gonna talk more about Tim’s experience here in a little bit.
[00:05:48] Joe: But OG, one question too before we go to our big interview, and I can’t wait for our stackers to, uh, to get this double dose of giving today from Tim and Adam Nash from Daffy. But OG, when you’re sitting with clients, is it you that’s bringing up giving? Are they bringing up giving? Like, where does giving sit in the financial plan?
[00:06:09] OG: It kind of depends. It’s either going to just kind of be who they are, and it’s just gonna come up in natural conversation. And then, you know, of course, our job is to try to find ways to make that a little bit more financial planning friendly. Yeah. You know? That’s, that’s not the goal, right? The goal is to serve and give and do that.
[00:06:26] OG: But then our job is to say, “Well, if you’re gonna do those things, is there a way we can do that in a way that is a little bit more beneficial to your tax situation, to the organization that you want to support? Can we help with that a little bit using whether donor-advised funds like we’ve talked about here, or charitable contributions from part of your required minimum distributions if you’re that old?”
[00:06:46] OG: So I think sometimes it’s just kind of a natural conversation. Sometimes it’s things we uncover on tax returns. It’s like, “Oh, are you doing, you know, $100 a week into your church envelope? Like, that’s awesome. Would you be open to a different way that could structure this a little bit differently from your, uh, financial planning standpoint?”
[00:07:03] OG: And then sometimes it’s just in the conversations we find out that it’s something they’ve wanted to do, but never really had any, you know, structure around how to think about it or what’s possible. You get to the point in your life when you’re financially independent or you’re moving in that direction, and you see that chart, and it doesn’t matter, you know, it doesn’t matter whether we’re doing it or you’re doing it, you know, on online, or you’re using Excel, and you go, “It says here I’m gonna die with a bajillion dollars at the end.”
[00:07:29] OG: It’s like, well, is there something we can do today that is more meaningful to you than, you know, leaving your kids and grandkids a whole bunch of money? Um, and you can still leave your grandkids and kids a bunch of money and, and also kind of engage with your community or the things- that are important to you right now.
[00:07:44] OG: So it’s kind of all of those three, right? We bring it up, we identify it, or it just kind of comes up in normal conversation if it’s something they’re already doing.
[00:07:51] Joe: Well, it’s gonna be an exciting episode. And we’re gonna be joined next by Adam Nash. He is the co-founder and CEO of Daffy, which is a donor-advised fund platform designed to help people make charitable giving a regular habit.
[00:08:05] Joe: Adam, uh, you may remember, OG, we had Adam on, uh, last year around this time, and it’s so much fun. In fact, I thought it’d be fun to have Tim and Adam together for a really dynamic conversation about helping all of us just see, to your point, what’s possible. Adam, I think, and Tim are the perfect dynamic duo because, Tim, you’re so involved in your personal community, and really your giving is around things that are intensely personal.
[00:08:31] Joe: Adam helps people that maybe haven’t developed that yet. They haven’t developed the local ties. And so I think we’ve got this great one-two punch. Now, Tim, you run three different scholarship programs, so we’ll get into those later on, that really have completely different focuses. Adam was president and CEO of this little company called Wealthfront.
[00:08:53] Joe: Not sure if you guys have heard of Wealthfront. He also was a leader at LinkedIn, Dropbox, eBay, and Apple, a few other small companies. We have the best of the best stackers between Tim and Adam. We’re gonna hear from both of them in just a couple minutes, but we have a couple sponsors who help us keep on keeping on, help us make this conversation and others free for you.
[00:09:15] Joe: So we’re gonna hear from them, and then Tim, Adam, and I diving into helping you become a better giver. Well, staying organized is a huge part of winning with your money. You’ll find out today that you wanna spend time with your community, not with your budgeting spreadsheet. FieldKit handles it all so you can focus on what’s most important.
[00:09:34] Joe: Head to fieldkitfinance.com to sign up and start living. That’s fieldkitfinance.com
[00:09:49] Joe: All right, Tim, we’re super happy. This gentleman’s back a year later and looking so much better. Adam Nash is here. How are you, man?
[00:09:57] Adam: Thanks for having me again. It’s great to be here.
[00:10:00] Joe: I want to start with this. When I was a financial planner, people would plan everything, very responsible people I’d work with.
[00:10:09] Joe: They’d automate their retirement contributions, they’d optimize their taxes, they’d insure things they forgot they owned, right? And then I’d say, “Okay, let’s talk about the giving plan,” and they’d go, “Oh, uh, you know, let’s do that, let’s do that later.” Why does giving seem to always be the last thing we tackle?
[00:10:27] Adam: I think it actually comes from a good place, which is that we don’t think of giving as just a financial task. It’s something more. We teach our children about it. We, i- it’s associated with our values, like how we live our lives. Unfortunately, I think that what that means is that we don’t put it in the same bucket where we put it in our budget, and for a lot of people, giving It involves actually making two very hard decisions.
[00:10:52] Adam: It’s number one, like, what can I afford to give, which is a financial question. Um, and the second one is, who do I give it to? What happens for most people is because they don’t plan for it, you get asked, a friend asks, a colleague asks, an organization reaches out, and then all of a sudden you have to answer both those questions on the spot.
[00:11:11] Adam: A, a lot of what we do at Daffy is trying to separate those two problems for people, right? Like, we, we actually encourage people, “Look, your financial plan, like your goals, your budget.” If you care about giving, and, and most Americans do care about giving, um, the smart thing to do is to put money aside for charity.
[00:11:28] Adam: I know it sounds old-fashioned. You, you put money aside for charity, and that way during times like the holiday season, et cetera, you can focus on the part that’s really rewarding, which is figuring out who you wanna give to that, that has the most impact for you and for the causes you care about.
[00:11:43] Joe: Yeah, and I definitely wanna talk about automating this a little bit, but I’m gonna save that for a little later.
[00:11:48] Tim: Sure.
[00:11:49] Joe: You spent almost your entire career working on financial platforms and working really with people’s behaviors. When was it, Adam, that you realized that giving was a behavior issue for a lot of us?
[00:12:04] Adam: I think it’s pretty obvious. You know, the great thing about looking at things from a financial perspective is it’s about dollars.
[00:12:09] Adam: It’s like, you know, dollars and cents. Everyone pretty much is making donations at some point or another. You know, end of the year, they’re doing this scramble of finding the donation receipts for their taxes and- Right. … “Wait, what did we give to the school last year,” right? These are the questions people ask.
[00:12:24] Adam: Um, and it’s meaningful, right? Like, the, the organizations that people belong to, it could be your kid’s school. It, it could be the church you go to. Um, it could be a cause that you really think is important. I teach this class at Stanford on personal finance for engineers. We just talk about, like, knowing what’s important in your life and making sure you’ve set up your financial life to help support what you wanna do in life in general.
[00:12:47] Adam: For most people, money is a means to an end, not the, the end by itself. And- When you put it that way, it seems obvious that giving should be in that bucket. It seems obvious that people care about it. And by the way, it’s a really big category. Uh, the last numbers I have, you know, I think a couple years ago, giving in the US was about 692 billion in the year, 50 to 60 million American households.
[00:13:09] Adam: And despite all the myths around it, most of that money just comes from individuals. That’s not like foundations, that’s not, um, the foundations and, and then corporations, et cetera, do give hundreds of billions a year, but the vast majority of the giving is from individuals. So when I looked at that, I was like, for me, that’s just like, we could do this better, right?
[00:13:28] Adam: Technology can help here. We’ve done so much in the last 10 to 15 years in fintech to make it easier to save better, spend better, invest better. You know, where’s the simple app? Where’s the simple service that helps people give better? And that’s really where Daffy came from.
[00:13:43] Joe: Do you remember actually where you were, Adam, when you decided that, you know what, I am gonna tackle this?
[00:13:49] Joe: Because it just seems, even as you talk about this, and so few people are focused on it as much as you are and Daffy is, do you remember where you were and when you went, “You know what? Let’s go ahead and let’s make this pivot and go”?
[00:14:00] Adam: I, I’ve worked in product and engineering most of my career, and so, um, I get excited about products all the time, like new ideas and that sort of thing.
[00:14:08] Adam: But, you know, like everyone in, in Silicon Valley, I have like the crib sheet of all these ideas, and most of them you don’t go after. And this idea around building a platform for giving, you know, reinventing the donor-advised fund went back years. But I, I do remember probably the moment that I can give the most credit for starting Daffy was my co-founder, Alejandro, right?
[00:14:28] Adam: He came over my… This is during the pandemic, by the way, so it’s not- Oh, man. … perfect timing, right? Like, literally, uh- … I’d been working on this idea for a while, talked to folks I trust, other founders, venture capitalists, people who build these platforms in fintech. Really thought it was a good idea, but, um, it was really that moment where I sat down, you know, with Alejandro and, and, and talked him through the idea, and he, he had done some work with DonorsChoose while we both worked at LinkedIn.
[00:14:53] Adam: He, he, he understood the space. He really kinda got the idea and, and, and, and loved just the values of the whole thing. I do think the pandemic affected things. It was a lot more obvious to a lot more people during the pandemic that, wait, we’re, we’re all in a community, right? This is hitting different people in different ways.
[00:15:12] Adam: Like, what are we doing to support each other? So I think that there was a real boom in kind of feeling about giving back and building platforms that help other people. But I remember the moment because, you know, you go through this and, you know, everyone thinks a startup just starts with an idea, and in some ways it does.
[00:15:28] Adam: But there’s that magic moment where someone else says like, “Hey, I’ll, I’ll, I’ll do this with you. Like I, I think that this is worth doing.” It’s like those videos that go around online, you know, you get the one random guy dancing and kinda looks goofy doing it and… But then a second person stands up and starts- Joins him and, yeah
[00:15:47] Adam: dancing and then, then all the, you know, all of a sudden you’ve got a party.
[00:15:49] Joe: Yes.
[00:15:49] Adam: But no, in, in all seriousness, I think a lot of startup platforms, people don’t realize how important the people are to make these platforms happen. It’s so easy to look at an app and a service and just see it for the features it has and tear apart the dollars and cents of it.
[00:16:03] Adam: But if I think about Daffy, it was that moment in the pandemic where we said, “No, w- this platform needs to be built and we think we can build it, and we think it will help a lot of people.” And, and so literally from that point, it was a matter of months before we had raised money and We were starting to hire and, and, and write code.
[00:16:19] Joe: Oh, it’s crazy quick turnaround. But it’s true, it’s that loneliness of the pandemic that I think made a lot of us realize how much we need community. Tim?
[00:16:29] Tim: Yeah. Well, I, I think you hit on a, uh, when you first started talking about how do you separate that decision from giving and then to whom I’m giving, and I think your platform does a amazing job on being able to make that really simple.
[00:16:42] Tim: As you look at your, uh, clients that have been in- involved for a number of years, how have you seen them evolve their giving? So, you know, maybe when, when they first start it’s like, okay, a little bit here and there, but h- have you been able to see how that evolves over time for, for those that are using the platform?
[00:16:58] Adam: I love this question because it kind of gets at the heart of what Daffy’s about and why I think in general donor-advised funds are actually a great platform for people’s giving, um, although I, I think that we’ve done a number of things to encourage it. Um, so we’re very metrics-oriented. We’re at heart, you know, a, a technology organization, so we have real data.
[00:17:16] Adam: We actually put it out earlier this year. We look at members who join Daffy, and we look at their giving every quarter, and we now have members who have been with us for years, so we can actually see how that expands over time. And almost to a T, every single cohort expands their giving over time. Hmm.
[00:17:34] Adam: It’s one thing to read research. We found research very similar to the famous research around retirement savings that said that if people pre-commit, if they automate their giving, they actually end up giving 32% more. But that’s academic research. You know, in practice, y- you know the old joke, right?
[00:17:52] Adam: What’s the, the difference between theory and practice? You guys know this joke? Am I the only one?
[00:17:58] Joe: No, I don’t.
[00:17:58] Adam: What’s the difference between theory and practice is, like, in theory, there is no difference, and in practice, there is.
[00:18:03] Joe: That’s right.
[00:18:04] Adam: And so, um, you know, it’s great to have the theory, but when we actually saw the data after having this platform live, we just celebrated our fifth birthday, and it really does make people more generous.
[00:18:13] Adam: I mean, that’s the mission of the organization. And I think it’s pretty simple. It turns out when you put money aside, it’s isolated for this goal, right? It’s for nothing else. So you have– you basically have mental accounting working for you with a little kicker from the tax code to, to make sure it’s really locked in, and then people use the money to give.
[00:18:31] Adam: A-and you know what? For the most part, when people give money to organizations they care about, they feel good about it, and they wanna do it again. And so what we see is that people use the money in the account, right? We, we set up a business model where we don’t make money just by storing assets, right?
[00:18:49] Adam: We, we make money– We’re a membership organization. So the longer people stay with us and the more they give over time, the better for Daffy and the better for the sector. And so it’s not totally surprising that we see these effects. And what we see classically is they get on the platform, they give. It usually starts with the contributions, and then they start looking for more places to give.
[00:19:11] Adam: When you take that problem of how much can I afford to give off the table, I mean, they have an app. That money is for nothing else. So when someone asks them to give, it, it’s a little bit of magic, right? That’s the magic moment of feeling like- Oh, I’m inspired. I want to give, and I have the money to do so.
[00:19:29] Adam: I- it just, it feels so good to people to just focus on the giving piece and not the, wait, if I write a check, i- is that in my budget? Um, what about- Yeah … wait, we, we had this other thing happen two weeks ago. Um, people’s budgets are hard for them, and I think you take giving out of that problem, you know, amazing things happen.
[00:19:48] Joe: It’s almost as if you take somebody, Adam, who’s initially just a charitably inclined person, and now you’ve turned it into a charitable giving plan that, uh, I can see over time as you see the effects of giving, not just on the community, but you. That’s what makes you wanna give more. True?
[00:20:06] Adam: Oh, yeah, for sure.
[00:20:06] Adam: I, I think that most people don’t start with a plan. I think it actually starts by being inspired. There’s some reason, some organization, some person that you trust or care about tends to come to you. I mean, this, this explains over 85% of giving, because someone asked. Different people have different passions and things that they care about and they prioritize, but one crosses a line, they give.
[00:20:31] Adam: And for some people, it’s just a one-off. They give once, and it happens here and there every year. And for others, they start getting involved. They care about the organization. They feel good. They care about the cause. This happens with children. I have four children. They were tiny once. They got big. If you keep feeding them, they, they keep growing, as it, it turns out.
[00:20:49] Adam: Isn’t that
[00:20:49] Joe: amazing how that works?
[00:20:50] Adam: Yeah.
[00:20:50] Joe: Direct correlation.
[00:20:51] Adam: It’s a lot, man. I have, uh, I have, like, 700 pounds of children now. It’s, it’s, it’s a lot. But fundamentally, um, people get involved, and then I think people do see over time that, wait, this is something I’ve been doing for a while, I should be more intentional about it.
[00:21:06] Adam: And the wonderful thing about a platform like Daffy is that by having all your giving in one place, you can kind of see the patterns. I mean, we do all the behavioral nudges, you know, you know. Robinhood might give you confetti for buying a stock or- Oh, man.
[00:21:17] Joe: Oh,
[00:21:18] Adam: no. … you know, or, or, um, you know, you might have platforms like Apple Health giving you the meter, like, have you gotten- Yeah
[00:21:23] Adam: your 10,000 steps in, et cetera.
[00:21:24] Joe: Right.
[00:21:25] Adam: We shamelessly borrow every feature that we think engages people for whatever, for shopping this… whatever, and we just use it for giving. Like, so you, you join Daffy, you set a giving goal. We celebrate you with confetti. We, we encourage you to make regular recurring donations.
[00:21:40] Adam: That counts towards your goal. And then every year we, we tell you how you did against your goal, and we, we nudge you a little bit to increase it. And it sounds basic, but, um, it turns out that the same things that get people out there to do another workout or buy something online, uh, you know, actually it works for giving as well.
[00:21:57] Joe: Tim, this is where I wanna bring you in even more because of the fact that Adam’s talking about charitably inclined people and setting that up on a recurring basis. For you, you were a first-generation college student. You were somebody who benefited a ton from scholarships that other people provided.
[00:22:16] Joe: When did you flip the switch to say, “You know what? I think I wanna be on the other side of this”?
[00:22:22] Tim: I think back to when I, uh, got my scholarships. The financial piece was, uh, really helpful, but so was the fact that someone else believed in you. That was the trigger for me as I set up the scholarship. I thought I was just doing a, a financial scholarship, and then I got a, a chance to connect with the students and get to watch them grow over that time period, and hearing from them how valuable that community was that you helped create as I bring those scholars together, versus it just being a, a financial transaction.
[00:22:50] Tim: That’s what giving is. Giving is, is having a chance to understand that organization and what it does, and the more you can connect yourself with that, the more passion there is, the more enjoyment, uh, and the more rewarding it is. So Adam, I completely agree with you on the, the way you’re gamifying the, the ability to get out and, and do those.
[00:23:09] Tim: One of the things I, I love about the app as I looked at it was the ability to bring the family members in and, and bring kids into, into this process of trying to think through how do, how, how do you start teaching that giving to the kids? So can you share a little bit more on, on how that has evolved over the time since you started the platform?
[00:23:26] Adam: Yeah, absolutely. Actually, the family plan, uh, and the family features has been amazingly popular. And it’s so funny ’cause, like most of our ideas at Daffy, we, we just get them from our members, right? So we, we had members who said, “Hey, my children are getting older. I wanna teach them about giving. How can I include them?”
[00:23:42] Adam: And I know it sounds funny ’cause it turns out, like most donor-advised funds out there, you go to the Fidelity, Schwabs, Vanguards, et cetera, they just feel like financial accounts. You know, it’s just, you know, oh, it could be a joint account, you know, with your spouse. I’ve had my four children on, on the account for a while.
[00:23:56] Adam: We actually support up to 24 members and, and we see people do all sorts of groupings, siblings get together, parents, grandparents with grandchildren. But really, the, the idea is very simple, like there’s still organizers. That’s what we call them. The, the donor advisors on the account are the ones who fund the account, et cetera.
[00:24:13] Adam: But you can add family members on and, and the great thing is really it’s two features. It’s the ability for your family members to see what you’re donating to. I mean, I can’t tell you how many people care about causes, care about organizations, and somehow their children never know. Right? I mean, even, even myself, like when I added my children to my family plan, we made our normal annual donation to, uh, the Monterey Bay Aquarium.
[00:24:39] Adam: We love supporting in the Bay Area, et cetera. They’ve been doing wonderful work for decades. And my children were like, “Wait, I didn’t know we supported them. When’s the last time we went? We should go again.” Like, you know, there was all this energy about it, talking about the work they do, et cetera. I mean, these days, you know, I hate to say it, but there’s, the, it’s hard to beat an app notification with your children to actually get them to notice something.
[00:25:00] Adam: I mean, they don’t always listen to everything else. And vice versa, then the ch- they can make their own recommendations. Once again, as a parent, I mean, h- everything has a family plan, like, you know, Amazon-
[00:25:11] Joe: Yeah …
[00:25:11] Adam: Netflix. I mean, like, the number of notifications I get from my teenagers for something that they wanna buy is not small.
[00:25:17] Adam: And so what… A wonderful thing that if they see an organization or something they’ve heard about or they care about, that they can recommend a donation, and then we can talk about it, and we can approve it, we can edit it, we can of course deny it if we wanted to Giving has a lot more in common with those features that you care about.
[00:25:34] Adam: Giving is not something you do in isolation. It, it is about people. It’s what you said, Tim. It’s about the people you support, it’s the connection, it’s the people in the organization you connect with, other people who give to the same thing. Like, there’s all these patterns. I, I’m somewhat known in the industry ’cause I was one of the early product leaders at LinkedIn through the IPO.
[00:25:54] Adam: I mean, we did a lot of work at LinkedIn to figure out how to bring professionals together, to bring people at work together as a, as a separate social sphere, and I think there’s a lot to be done around giving in the same way. Our angle, of course, is that, like, we’re just trying to take, make the financial piece easy, right?
[00:26:10] Adam: Like, so if, if you wanna donate cash, if you wanna donate stock, if you wanna donate crypto, whatever you wanna donate, we’ll make it as easy as possible for you to put that aside for charities so that you can focus on really the magic, which is the, the human piece, the, the giving piece.
[00:26:25] Joe: I’ve got two questions, Adam.
[00:26:26] Joe: First one is after your kids found out that you were giving to the wonderful aquarium, which, you know, I’m here in Texas, but I’ve been to that aquarium. It’s so beautiful. Tim, have you been to the Monterey Aquarium?
[00:26:37] Tim: I have not made it there,
[00:26:38] Joe: no. Oh, you gotta go. It’s incredible. But I can just imagine, Adam, your kids walking in going, “Do you know who I am?
[00:26:44] Joe: We support this place. We…” “I get to pet all the stingrays.” No?
[00:26:49] Adam: No. But, you know, it’s one of the reasons we actually structured Daffy the way we did. I mean, we… You know, it’s, it’s very funny. I was talking with someone who runs a, another donor-advised fund, and they were just fascinated by the fact that we call the people who use Daffy members, and we did it on purpose.
[00:27:03] Adam: I, I think, you know, actually Monterey Bay Aquarium is, is a membership-based organization.
[00:27:07] Joe: Sure.
[00:27:08] Adam: A lot of great nonprofits are. Um, when you’re trying to build a relationship, uh, you know, with folks that you wanna have over a long time, I actually think membership is a wonderful framework to use for giving.
[00:27:19] Adam: And so thankfully my, I don’t think my kids do that. Um, but- … um, I, I, I think there’s a different feeling when you walk into a place where you feel like you belong.
[00:27:28] Joe: Yes.
[00:27:29] Adam: It softens you in a different way. You’re a little bit more open. You listen a little bit more. It’s a little less of entertain me or show me what you’ve done, and a little bit more of like, what are we doing?
[00:27:41] Adam: There’s that aspect to it, and I, I do think that for giving and successful giving, for a lot of people it ties to their identity, and I think they enjoy feeling like they’re a part of something that matters. And so I think that affects people when they join Daffy, and I think that affects people when they give to organizations they care about.
[00:27:58] Joe: I’ve known Tim long enough to know, Tim, it’s definitely a part of your identity, just the fact that you’re a part of the community and that you give, and it’s just exciting to see how much you get from that. I love talking about how you’ve made this platform to get rid of friction, right? In, in, in money we talk about friction all the time, and eliminating friction, or in some places adding friction when it really is costing you money.
[00:28:23] Joe: While different places are try- Amazon is trying to make it easier for you to one-click buy, you know, maybe we put some friction in the way. But I want to widen this out further, because you have a front row seat, Adam, on this. A lot of Stackers already give. How do we become a smarter giver?
[00:28:43] Adam: Well, there’s two big things going on, and have been going on for a while.
[00:28:47] Adam: One is really about the value of just putting money aside when things are good. A lot of people think of giving, they support organizations, they do it the same way every year. But the truth is, for most households, most Americans, the data’s been clear for decades, our income is getting more volatile. We have good years and not so good years.
[00:29:08] Adam: And by the way, as an investor, we, we all know this. Sometimes Mr. Market is happy and, and sometimes he’s depressed. The idea of putting aside money for charity in the good years, it’s invested tax-free, but that means you have money to give in the not so good years. And I, I, I think that most people really hate that feeling when you’re in one of those not so good years and an organization you belong to asks, as they do every year, feeling like you can’t do it, that it, it just, it, it hits you in a different place.
[00:29:38] Adam: This isn’t like saying, “Oh, we, we need to eat at home more,” you know, we’re eating out too much on the expenses of that sort of thing. Th- this is much more like, “Oh, I don’t feel good about not being able to support this year.” And so the power of putting money aside, I mean, our tax code rewards it, right? We have a progressive tax system.
[00:29:55] Adam: Your tax rates are literally higher in the good years than the not so good years. So the entire system makes it obvious that you should be putting money aside in those good years and knowing that if you put aside money for one year, two years, three years of giving, that’s fine. That, that financial goal is taken care of.
[00:30:12] Adam: It’s kinda like putting money aside for retirement. I think the second big trend though that’s, that’s been monstrous the last few years is more and more people are realizing that the smart way to donate is to donate stock.
[00:30:24] Joe: Mm.
[00:30:24] Adam: Appreciate investments. This used to be something that only, you know, executives and, you know, investors would think about, but now it’s really across the board.
[00:30:34] Adam: More and more people are realizing that, wait, when I donate stock that’s appreciated, or it could be crypto or anything, I mean, like, for most people it’s stock, you actually win three ways. When you donate stock, you get to write off as a charitable deduction the, the market value of the stock, right? Not what you bought it at.
[00:30:51] Adam: If you held it more than a year, you get to write off the value. So even a boring index fund, I love boring index funds, by the way, but if you invested in Vanguard Total Market 10, 15 years ago, actually a lot of that is capital gains. A lot of it And so the second benefit, of course, is not only do you get to write off the current market value without reaching into your pocket for cash, but second is you’ll never pay the capital gains tax on that stock.
[00:31:18] Adam: So most people don’t really account for that, but when you buy a stock at $10 and it runs up to 50, that, I mean, that’s a huge win, of course. But you don’t really have $40 because, you know, I, I live in California, you know, but wherever you live, some portion of that is gonna go to the government to taxes.
[00:31:35] Joe: Yeah.
[00:31:35] Adam: Which actually means you’ll have less money, and that also means you’ll have less money to give. Not having to pay the capital gains taxes on some of your shares with the lowest cost basis, I mean, the math kind of does itself there. And then, of course, the additional benefit of the fact that when you put stock in a donor-advised fund, it’s gonna be invested tax-free and available whenever you wanna make a donation recommendation.
[00:32:00] Adam: That’s like a third way you win. So I think that more and more people are figuring that out, and that’s part of the boom I think that’s been going on with donor-advised funds in general, is that when people hear about this, it just-
[00:32:11] Joe: Yeah …
[00:32:11] Adam: honestly, it just, it just makes sense. I mean, the biggest problem with donor-advised funds is just that most people haven’t heard of them.
[00:32:15] Joe: No, that is a huge thing, and I just remember back in the day, and we still get letters sometimes to Stacking Benjamins, Adam, about, uh, people that are like, “Hey, I’m, I’m gonna sell this stock and write a check.” You’re like, “No, please, please don’t,” because it’s less money to everybody except Uncle Sam, and like, uh, one of our guests said, he’s not even your real uncle.
[00:32:35] Joe: Tim, you had a question?
[00:32:36] Tim: You know, one of the things that I couldn’t agree with you more on is in, uh, doing appreciated securities. It makes so much sense to do that. One of the things that your platform, uh, looks to allow is that you can give the, the stock and actually then let the donor decide at what point do they sell it a- and turn it into cash or reinvest it in something else.
[00:32:55] Tim: I know most donor-advised funds have the policy out there that says they sell that stock upon receipt, and then you, you can invest it in that. Talk a little bit about that, that feature, and do you see that used a lot on the platform?
[00:33:08] Adam: Oh, it, it’s immensely popular. We, we rolled it out last year. It’s been a huge driver.
[00:33:13] Adam: And, and actually, just to clarify, um, a couple things, the truth is actually most donor-advised funds will take your recommendations for whether to hold stock or sell it if you’re wealthy.
[00:33:25] Joe: Hmm.
[00:33:25] Adam: If you have more than five million dollars on the platform, if you, um, you can get an advisor associated with your donor-advised fund, and, and they can actually make recommendations like that.
[00:33:37] Adam: The big difference with Daffy is we just provide that to everyone. We– It, it’s not just for folks who have millions of dollars in the account. The issue with donor-advised funds is actually, just to clarify, is you can’t make that decision. So all donor-advised funds have policies because the reason that you get the tax deduction is it’s an irrevocable donation.
[00:33:56] Adam: You are giving up control of the stock. And so donor-advised funds say like, “Well, if you give us a stock, that, that’s wonderful, very generous, but we’re gonna liquidate it immediately and reinvest it in a portfolio,” almost like a 401k, like they have pre-built portfolios. What we decided at Daffy is that that was getting in the way of giving, that there were a lot of reasons when people were thinking about donating stock It would create anxiety.
[00:34:20] Adam: It, it’s not that they didn’t want the stock sold or that wasn’t the right financial decision, but that was an extra decision they had to make before making the decision of donating stock. Mm. And so our entire f- once again, we’re all grounded in behavioral finance here. It was like, let’s separate those decisions.
[00:34:36] Joe: You’re just eliminating more friction, Adam.
[00:34:38] Adam: Yes. If you bought NVIDIA four years ago, and it’s run up tremendously, turns out sometimes winners win. But you believe in NVIDIA, you believe in the AI cycle, you believe the appreciation. We didn’t want anything getting in the way. We didn’t want people thinking, like, market timing, like, “Well, I’ll donate that stock down the road when it’s higher.
[00:34:57] Adam: I still think it has room to run.” No, no, no. We want you to put that money aside for charity now. And so if, if giving us a recommendation saying, “Hey, I, I’m gonna donate 1,000 shares of NVIDIA, but I, I want it sold down gradually over the next three years,” I recommend holding it. They’re all recommendations, but you know, we set up an investment policy where we look at that recommendation and say, “Oh, yeah, actually we do think that’s for our mission in, in terms of getting more generosity, more money to charities, and, um, it fits in our investment policy, et cetera.”
[00:35:29] Adam: And so, you know, happy to do that. I know it sounds funny, but literally the feature that we do, we let our members actually tell us, make that recommendation. And, and by the way, we do the same thing with, uh, portfolios, right? We have a bunch of pre-built portfolios, but if for your personal giving you recommend a different portfolio and it conforms to our investment policy, um, like I said, other platforms will let you do that if you have millions of dollars.
[00:35:52] Joe: Yeah.
[00:35:53] Adam: We just let everyone do it.
[00:35:55] Joe: I want to end our time together by solidifying the stuff that we talked about and kind of bringing it full circle with a game. We’re in mom’s basement, we have to play games, but I think it brings home some of the messages and the points so everybody clearly understands what we’re talking about.
[00:36:10] Joe: Tim, you’re gonna play too. We’re gonna call this Check, Stock, or Donor-Advised Fund? I’m gonna give you a stacker, and Adam, you’re gonna tell us which one to explore first. Do you just write a check? Do you give the organization stock, or do you use a donor-advised fund? And then Tim, because you serve on nonprofit boards, I’d like you to tell me what either the donor or the nonprofit might be thinking, all right, around each one of these people.
[00:36:35] Joe: Scenario one, a stacker just starting out, Adam, gives about $500 a year. It’s a nice amount, but it is all they can do. Not the five mil we were talking about a few minutes ago. And it’s usually in small donations to a handful of different organizations. Write a check, stock, or donor-advised fund?
[00:36:56] Adam: I know this is gonna shock people.
[00:36:57] Adam: I’m actually gonna say donor-advised fund. That person most likely doesn’t give continuously through the year. They probably make a few more donations in the holiday season, maybe in the spring for a school, et, et cetera, and reaching into their pocket and finding even $500 can be disruptive. That’s a big ask.
[00:37:20] Adam: The benefits of just setting up a system where you put aside $10 a week, $25 a month, you can line it up with your payroll just automatically so that the money is there when you want to give. The big benefit is just now you have it all in one place.
[00:37:36] Joe: Mm.
[00:37:36] Adam: You can make it recurring if you want. You can always say, “Oh, did I already give to this place?”
[00:37:40] Adam: Just having all your giving in one place and setting up a system for it, that actually for our members, and our… By the way, our, our average member actually looks a lot like that. Um, a few hundred dollars, a few thousand dollars a year. There’s immense value in just having a separate account for that.
[00:37:57] Joe: And to be clear too, the nonprofit, $50 cash versus $50 from a donor-advised fund, I can’t imagine they care where it comes from.
[00:38:06] Tim: No, they’ll happily accept it in either way. If the donor is been doing it for a little while, and they have a, uh, a donor-advised fund set up, having it through the donor-advised fund would be the great way to do it. If it’s someone who doesn’t know what a donor-advised fund is, that doesn’t have that experience, they’re probably gonna lean towards the cash or check route just because it’s easier.
[00:38:25] Tim: There’s less friction there. I think we all have an opportunity to tell the story of what donor-advised funds can do for a donor.
[00:38:33] Joe: Well, and this is where I like, Adam, the gamification too because now if I’m getting nudges from you to give more, it just makes me feel so much better and better every year that this is on the plate and not the last thing.
[00:38:44] Joe: You know, it’s not dessert. It’s part of my overall plan. Scenario number two, Stacker gives $5,000 a year, owns highly appreciated ETFs, supports six or seven charities. Do they just give the stock, write a check, donor-advised fund?
[00:39:01] Adam: I hate to say it, u- unless they have exactly one charity that they want to give that stock to and, and it’s a large one that can handle a stock gift, ’cause most actually can’t, I think you’re using a donor-advised fund there too.
[00:39:15] Adam: And the extra benefit, I would say particularly for that person, given the tax code, is remember, with the tax bill that went through last year, there’s a real benefit to bunching. The real benefit for that person is not putting aside $5,000 worth of stock every year for five years and missing most of the tax deduction they would get.
[00:39:36] Adam: It would be finding a way to put aside 10,000 or $20,000 worth of stock into a donor-advised fund. It’s now invested tax-free. They now clear the hurdle-
[00:39:46] Joe: The hurdle …
[00:39:47] Adam: to get that tax deduction that year, and now they can make donations to any charity, not just ones that take stock. And by the way, they can divide it up how they want.
[00:39:57] Adam: They can make a $50 donation. They can make a $500 donation. Whereas when you’re donating stock, you end up with this kind of funny lumpiness, right? Mm-hmm. Like, it kind of rewards one big donation, but it’s hard to subdivide, especially when you support a lot of different organizations. So this is actually part of the boom that’s been going on the last couple years, is that because of the tax bill, people are realizing that instead of giving the same amount every year and putting aside the same amount every year, that actually there’s a huge benefit to putting aside the money early, getting that tax deduction, and then using a donor-advised fund to actually smooth out the giving so you can give for three, four, five years off the money you put aside in that one year where you were feeling flush, where you were feeling good, feeling like you can put that money aside.
[00:40:44] Joe: I had another scenario that I’ll just cut to the chase. You know, somebody gets a, has a huge year bonus-wise. They work on commission, or maybe they’re in real estate, or they sell a business, whatever it might be. That stacking also works well there too, like you said before, to, to get between the boom-bust years.
[00:41:01] Joe: Tim, question for you. I got to imagine that most charitable organizations, like if you try to hand them stock, y- you just created some, some friction for them versus the donor-advised fund taking care of it.
[00:41:15] Tim: You absolutely do. And, and, you know, for the larger organizations, they’re, they’re used to having stock.
[00:41:20] Tim: For a smaller organization, they, they just don’t know what to do with it. I’m a big believer that you do the stock into a donor-advised fund, and then you let the donor-advised fund piece it out. The other good thing with that is when you’re giving stock, you don’t know exactly the value it’s gonna be when it lands in the donor-advised fund.
[00:41:36] Tim: So you, you know kind of what it was when you initiated it, but it might be a day or two different, and you could be a couple hundred dollars off. Whereas when you put it in there, then turn around and give a g- grant out of the donor-advised fund, I can say, “I want $100 specifically to go to that, that organization.”
[00:41:51] Joe: Specific. Yeah. Adam, who doesn’t need a donor-advised fund?
[00:41:55] Adam: Um, people who don’t give. Believe it or not, like, I actually think this is important because there’s some people who get so spun up about taxes, it, it’s almost like the tail starts wagging the dog. They just start looking for every place. This idea of like, “Oh, I can put stock in a donor-advised fund and not pay the capital gains taxes and get a, a write-off.”
[00:42:15] Adam: That’s great, but that money is on a one-way trip. That money does not come back. This is why I love it, uh, from a giving standpoint, but you’re putting money aside for charity, and so I do acknowledge the fact that for some people their giving journey begins that way. They are motivated by the taxes. They put money aside with the confidence that they’ll find organizations to give to, ’cause by the way, they mostly do, so that it does work out.
[00:42:40] Adam: But I’m actually a big believer at Daffy that for the most part the donor-advised fund is… I mean, you can just look at your, your bank statement, whatever online tool you use to track your finances, um, your tax return. Like if, if you give to charity even a few times a year, I think the donor-advised fund is exactly the right thing to use, and it will not only lower your tax bill, it, it will also, um, frankly make you more generous.
[00:43:04] Adam: So I think it’s a wonderful thing. Yeah, I tell the whole team here at Daffy that our focus is to help people who give be more generous, be the people that they want to be and, and do it in the best way possible. But I, I don’t think it’s like everyone should have a donor-advised fund, right? Like there, there are some financial products where I feel like no, no, everyone should have this.
[00:43:22] Joe: Yeah.
[00:43:23] Adam: I think the donor-advised fund is really for those 50 to 60 million American households who give to charity every year. I, I think that it’s very, very useful to have a separate account set aside where all your giving happens, and you can be more intentional about it. And then I think the tax benefits are just icing on the cake there for the benefits.
[00:43:42] Joe: Tim, from, uh, the nonprofit side, what makes a donor an easy person to work with for the organization?
[00:43:50] Tim: Well, the thing that makes a donor the best is when you can find someone that has a passion for your work and that you can be a partner in it and ideate together of kind of what’s the impact you wanna make for the, the organization.
[00:44:02] Tim: That’s the ideal. Uh, you think about it as a donor continuum, and you know, a-as I’m from a fundraising perspective, you look at a, at a donor as like how can I make it that every interaction I have with that donor moves them up that continuum, makes them feel more connected to the organization, gets them more invested in the future?
[00:44:19] Tim: So you move it from a transactional to a transformational relationship over time. That’s the key that you want, and it’s like every time you’re interacting with that person, y-you’re moving yourself one way or the other on that continuum, and you wanna be creating to move them up.
[00:44:34] Joe: Is there anything that we do that unintentionally makes things harder?
[00:44:39] Tim: I think donor stewardship is one that so many organizations get wrong. They accept the donation, but then they don’t necessarily thank or they don’t look at ways of, okay, how do I engage, uh, this donor? And therefore, the next time it comes around for them to make that decision of where am I gonna give to, they think back as, “Well, I r- I really haven’t heard anything from that organization,” or, “I d- I don’t know what the impact was that happened from the gift that I gave them,” and they move on to the next thing.
[00:45:04] Tim: So I think donor stewardship is a key piece of trying to figure out, okay, how do I connect with this donor?
[00:45:10] Joe: Adam, you and I discussed this when we had this amazing conversation last year. For people that didn’t hear it, I wanna revisit something, which is … And it’s a criticism I still hear this year, is that we get the tax deduction when the money goes in, and a lot of people, to your point, uh, I li- I love the phrase that the tax tail, you know, wagging the dog.
[00:45:29] Joe: People get excited about that, but the charity doesn’t get the money until it comes out. Is it fair criticism that, uh, Donor Advised Fund becomes this charitable parking lot instead of getting the money to the organizations that need it?
[00:45:45] Adam: It, it’s always interesting. I, I understand why people have these concerns, you know, for sure.
[00:45:49] Adam: And it, it’s because actually, listen, all, all these charities, all these organizations are doing such good work. And by the way, they need support. There’s more they could do. Like, we’re, we’re very much in the camp of, like, there is more to do. I mean, Daffy was founded on this idea that if we can increase generosity, as big as the numbers are in the US, and like I said, it’s about 2% of GDP if you measure it that way, we are actually the crazy platform that thinks it could be bigger, right?
[00:46:14] Adam: Like, we could, we could free up trillions of dollars more for charity. But I think people who have this criticism are, are missing the forest for the trees. I mean, there’s a reason endowments exist, right? Like, none of these problems and causes get solved in one year, right? If you talk to most organizations, they want ongoing support.
[00:46:31] Adam: And so there’s a reason why you get the tax deduction when you put money aside for retirement now, right? But you’re not- Even though you don’t use it for retirement later. College savings, right? Like, any long-term goal. And I, I… So I think the mistake that people make is they think of giving in this transactional lens of, like, the number this year.
[00:46:52] Adam: They think about money going out this year versus what’s gonna create the most giving and the most charitable support over time. I mean, I, I actually think that most nonprofits are waking up to this idea of, of actually talking to their donor-advised fund donors differently than the transactional donors.
[00:47:11] Adam: That can be a long-term relationship. They have an account where they can not only make recurring donations, but they, they could be supporting you for years or, or decades. I think that most organizations are used to doing that at the very high end, right? Like, they run these campaigns, they have anchors, they, they have folks, et cetera, who’ve donated regularly.
[00:47:30] Adam: But I think that when people have a donor-advised fund, I mean, the data is really incontrovertible. It makes people more generous. Yeah. More money ends up going to charity. So I guess it just comes down to what you think the tax code is for.
[00:47:41] Joe: You explained that last year, and I heard it throughout the year, and I’m like, “I just want you standing next to me, Adam.”
[00:47:47] Joe: But I’m like, “No, no, no, talk to this guy.” Uh, Tim, you had one more question before we say goodbye.
[00:47:53] Tim: Yeah. One of the biggest things I’ve found personally and that I’ve talked to a lot of others that have donor-advised funds to encourage them is the power of using donations with the idea of a matching gift.
[00:48:04] Tim: Talking to the organization and saying, “Hey, you know, I’ll give $1,000 for here, and please use this as a, as a matching gift so that as you go out and raise additional dollars from others, they can look at it as, uh, boy, if we raise this, we get this matching gift.” And all of a sudden you’re leveraging your ability to make an impact.
[00:48:24] Tim: I know when I was first starting giving, uh, that drove me to give differently, and now I can be on the other side of that, creating that donor or that, uh, match pool to encourage others to give.
[00:48:35] Adam: Not only do I agree with Tim 100% on this, we actually have proof of this. So we rolled out this feature. No other donor-advised fund has it, but we heard the same thing from our members.
[00:48:45] Adam: We heard how much more doing matching gifts meant to them a- and organizations, and so we rolled out on our platform. So now any donor-advised holder can run a matching campaign for up to 15 nonprofits, by the way, at a time, and, um, just automatically set it up so that every time someone donates $10, $20, $100 to that charity, they’ll match it up to a certain amount And our members love it.
[00:49:11] Adam: They, they get the… Every time someone makes a donation on their campaign, they get alert on their phone and the match automatically comes out of the DAF. We treat it as basically a, a scheduled recommended donation that we just auto-approve, um, ’cause we already approved it, right? So we, we approve it- Yeah
[00:49:27] Adam: again. But it just works out. And it, it seems so obvious, ’cause online campaigns have been around for decades, right? Like, this is not, like, a new feature. It’s just no one really thought of using a donor-advised fund that way. But Tim, we’ve had members tell us that they only wanna do matching campaigns.
[00:49:44] Joe: That’s
[00:49:44] Adam: cool. Right? Like, they, they find it so much more rewarding. Like, rather than give $1,000, rather than give 10,000, 100,000, whatever the dollar amount is, they feel like when they do it as a matching campaign that they’re bringing others to the charity, that they’re bringing other people into the community, and they just love it.
[00:50:03] Adam: And they get that effect. If you have any other great ideas for us to turn into product- … please let me know. That’s what we live to do. I
[00:50:09] Joe: will tell you, Adam, hanging out with Tim just a little bit, he- he’ll keep them coming. Yeah, great. He’s always got a bunch. Thank you so much for helping us reduce friction and become better givers.
[00:50:20] Joe: It is so important. And I love also, you know, just the idea of the family plan, right? I’d encourage everybody with a family to get your family involved like you mentioned earlier, Adam. I think it’s so important. Thanks for helping our Stackers become better givers today. I really appreciate it.
[00:50:37] Adam: Always happy to be here.
[00:50:38] Adam: And all jokes aside, I love the ideas, et cetera. Actually, some of our discussion, we love so much getting families started, uh, et cetera. You know, we’ve, we’ve made it easy now for members to send funds from their fund to another fund. So if you have a, an older child, right, like some of mine are now, et cetera, and you wanna get them started on their giving journey, like, we try to make that easy.
[00:50:59] Adam: But, um, I, I think there’s a lot here to do. I mean, the exciting thing for the Daffy team is that there really are so many good people involved with so many organizations, and I feel like they’ve had ideas for decades of ways we could do this better, and they’ve just been missing a technology platform that just actually is built for one reason and one reason only, is it to make those ideas come to life.
[00:51:22] Adam: And so, um, it’s been delightful. We just celebrated our fifth birthday, but I always love coming here and, and talking about the different ways that people can lead healthier financial lives and incorporate giving into what they do. And, and hopefully we’ll keep seeing the generosity grow.
[00:51:36] Joe: What discourages me, Adam, is you’re clearly not fired up about it like that.
[00:51:40] Joe: If you could just get some excitement around this whole giving thing. It’s daffy.org, Stackers. We’ll link to it on our show notes. Again, Adam, thanks for joining us.
[00:51:49] bumper: Hi, I’m Jamila Souffrant, and when I’m not helping people launch to financial freedom, I’m stacking Benjamins.
[00:52:00] Doug: Hey there, Stackers. I’m Joe’s mom’s neighbor, Doug, and on this day back in 1983, one of the greatest Christmas movies of all time hit theaters, A Christmas Story. That’s right, the movie about Ralphie Parker, his slightly dysfunctional family, and the kind of childhood Christmas memories that usually take about six years of therapy to unpack.
[00:52:20] Doug: Not to make this about me, but that sounds exactly like an episode of Stacking Benjamins, doesn’t it? The movie eventually became a holiday classic. Flick gets his tongue frozen to a flagpole. How awesome was that? Ralphie’s little brother, Randy, bundled up so tightly he can’t even put his arms down, and of course, Ralphie’s dad wins a major award, a beautiful, I mean beautiful, lamp shaped like a woman’s leg, complete with fishnet stockings, very similar, I might add, to the ones I’m wearing right now.
[00:52:49] Doug: By the way, Joe, I actually tried giving one of those lamps as a Christmas present once, ’cause I’m into the, you know, charitable giving thing. I thought it would really class up the joint, but my church said they already had one.
[00:52:59] Joe: Oh, bummer.
[00:53:00] Doug: Yeah, Salvation Army wouldn’t take it either. It was really weird.
[00:53:03] Doug: Here’s the heart of our trivia question, though. At the center of the whole movie is Ralphie, a kid who wants one particular Christmas present more than anything in the world. He dreams about it. He drops hints to his parents. Heck, he even makes his case to Santa himself. For the record, that’s considerably more effort than I put into my Christmas list.
[00:53:22] Doug: I just write cash on a Post-It Note and slap it on Joe’s forehead while he’s sleeping. It’s not cute at all. Not funny. Yeah. So here it i- here it is, the question today. In the 1983 holiday classic, A Christmas Story, what was that awesome Christmas gift Ralphie Parker wanted more than anything else? I’ll be back right after I check the tracking number on my major award.
[00:53:46] Doug: Seller says it’s fragile, so you know, it’s probably coming from Italy.
[00:53:58] Doug: Hey there, Stackers. I’m certified Christmas gift consultant and guy who once got banned from a Secret Santa exchange for submitting an invoice, Joe’s mom’s neighbor, Doug. Look, I mean, they said the spending limit was 20 bucks, but they never said I couldn’t charge for labor. Gift wrapping is a marketable skill, people.
[00:54:15] Doug: Before the break, I told you about A Christmas Story, the 1983 holiday classic featuring a leg lamp, a frozen flagpole, and one very determined kid named Ralphie Parker. And while the rest of his family is busy dealing with furnace problems, the Bumpus hounds, and a Christmas turkey that doesn’t quite survive the holiday, Ralphie got his heart set on one particular gift.
[00:54:38] Doug: So what was it? It was a Red Ryder carbine action 200-shot range model air rifle, or as most of us know it, a Red Ryder BB gun. But, you know, the longer version’s so much more fun. And of course, every adult Ralphie asks gives him the same warning, “You’ll shoot your eye out, kid,” which seems a, a little harsh, crushing his dreams like that.
[00:55:00] Doug: When I was a kid, the adults in my life were much more encouraging. I mean, my Uncle Earl once gave me a chainsaw for my eighth birthday. Oh, my. He didn’t even wrap it. Oh, my. He just left it running in the driveway. Said, “Have a bl- have a blast, kid.” Anyway, Ralphie finally gets his dream gift and almost immediately discovers that maybe the grown-ups had a point.
[00:55:19] Doug: And that, Stackers, is why you should always keep the receipt. See ya.
[00:55:25] Joe: Maybe they did have a point. By the way, in Northwest Arkansas is Rogers, Arkansas, which is the home of the Red Rider BB gun. Have you been to Rogers, OG, as you’ve crossed the, crisscrossed the state up there by Bentonville?
[00:55:39] OG: I, um, I haven’t stopped.
[00:55:41] OG: Maybe I waved.
[00:55:43] Joe: It is a beautiful little downtown. You think of these iconic little downtowns, the railroad track running through the middle of town.
[00:55:49] OG: Mm. Those are my favorite when you’re driving- Right … and you’ve got a place to go, and you’ve got the one railroad track that you get to stop at- You can barely hear yourself think.
[00:55:56] OG: Just that charming … for some indeterminate amount of time. Those are my favorite. There’s one of those on the way to College Station too, right in, like- Oh, they are … some- the, the town right before you get to College Station. It’s like, “Great. Great. This is awesome. This is, uh, so close to my goal, and now I get to stop for 30 minutes.”
[00:56:11] OG: Yeah. Or 40 or 10.
[00:56:12] Doug: They’re herding cattle through the streets.
[00:56:15] Joe: That’s right. You gotta stop and smell the roses, OG. Or in this case, smell the brakes from the train. Ain’t nobody
[00:56:20] OG: got time for rose-smelling on my schedule.
[00:56:23] Joe: Well, it’s… Well, big thanks to, to Adam for joining us. I wanna pivot from the discussion that we had with Adam a moment ago, Tim, and number one, talk about your scholarships in particular.
[00:56:36] Joe: You know, for a lot of people, when they’re, when they’re getting started, having a donor-advised fund is a great idea. Just getting involved, building the muscle’s a great idea. But you take this another step. You support your community theater. You support scholars. Talk a little bit about what the next step might be here beyond setting up a donor-advised fund.
[00:56:56] Tim: Well, I first started, and I gave a little bit of dollars to a lot of different places, and I think you evolve over time. You think, you, you get en- engaged with, and you say, “Hey, where can I have the biggest impact?” So over the years, it’s gotten to be a little bit larger gifts to s- a smaller number of organizations because I think I can have the biggest impact.
[00:57:14] Tim: So there’s a lot of different ways that you can do that. You can do that through a donor-advised fund, which I’m a huge fan of. Lets you put some dollars in at the end of one year, but you don’t have to necessarily give it all out in one year. You can spread it out over a time into multiple organizations.
[00:57:26] Tim: So for me, that’s been great. I also benefited greatly from scholarships in undergrad, and because of that, I s- decided I wanted to start a scholarship at my undergrad and my grad institutions. With that, you know, you think about it, it’s like, “Man, how can I do that?” That’s a huge amount of dollars. Right.
[00:57:42] Tim: But if you actually look at it and you look for some of the programs, you can actually do it much more potentially reasonably. So for myself, I w- worked for General Mills. We had an amazing gift matching program. So I give a dollar, and it gets matched n- another dollar. The University of Minnesota at that same time had a, the similar program where they were encouraging endowments, so they doubled that.
[00:58:01] Tim: So now one to two to four. Oh, my
[00:58:03] Joe: goodness.
[00:58:04] Tim: You use, you use appreciated securities, and you get your tax deduction. I think it cost me 17 cents on the dollar. So when you step back and you look at it, you think, “Okay, this is a huge amount, this $50,000 endowment.” Well, if you break it down into the different matches and everything I had, it cost me $2,500 a year for five years.
[00:58:21] Tim: So much more accessible- … than to think about what you had to do to m- to make that 50 to start with.
[00:58:27] Joe: It’s amazing, OG, when we just do a little research on these things like Tim did. Just look into the matching gift how much further your money can go.
[00:58:34] OG: Yeah, I also like, Tim, what you were talking about, about as you get older, you find the things that are more important to you and kind of concentrating your, your energy, you know, whatever that looks like, into the things that are most important.
[00:58:46] OG: I believe strongly in that.
[00:58:48] Tim: Well, and I also found that if I tie what I give to to also the organizations I’m volunteering with and on the boards of, it, it all brings it together, and you can make an even bigger impact in those communities. Yeah. The other thing I love to tell to my friends is friends don’t let friends give cash.
[00:59:02] Tim: It’s very inefficient. So with that, you know, using, taking advantage of the stock, appreciated securities to give, so much better than giving cash. And through a donor advise fund or through a, an individual organization, you can do that so much easier today than you could in the past.
[00:59:17] Joe: Yeah. I also, though, guys, like the first step of what you said, Tim, which was initially you gave to a lot of places, and I think my problem when I was younger and I was just starting off on the giving journey, I didn’t know what I was passionate about.
[00:59:31] Joe: In fact, I remember talking to a coach of mine going, “My problem is all my clients seem to be passionate about all these things. I’m not passionate about .” Like, I just didn’t feel passionate. So I had to just begin volunteering in different places. I, I volunteered with a Arthritis Foundation event that they had.
[00:59:50] Joe: One of my clients was the president of the Arthritis Foundation. Then I realized my mom had arthritis. Then I found out about juvenile arthritis, and all of a sudden, I found out that this thing that I just went to help work at a 5K to help somebody locally, there was a lot more depth once I let my feet do the walking than trying to sit and figure out what my big aha was gonna be.
[01:00:14] Joe: Like, what the, what the organization was gonna be. When you’re just starting out, I think that’s a great approach, Tim. Just get out there. Get out there and, and see what fits and what doesn’t.
[01:00:25] Tim: Well, I think that’s an, a very important piece because I think in, in our minds we’ve set up this, uh, make it bigger than it has to be.
[01:00:30] Tim: It’s like, oh, if I go do this one event, I have to commit to it for the next 12 years.
[01:00:34] Joe: Right.
[01:00:35] Tim: Not true. You go and you try it one time and, you know, I’ve done many things where I went one time, great experience, but s- that’s not for me. You move on. And I think as, as long as we have that curiosity and go and try different things, it gives us a chance to see what really fits for us.
[01:00:48] Tim: Where do we think we can have the biggest impact, and where can we have the best connection to what we really care for?
[01:00:54] Joe: I want to talk, Tim, about the scholars that you support A lot of people think, and you said, and I love that line, “Friends don’t let friends give cash.” But I also think giving your time or wrapping it more into how can we help each other in different ways really helps.
[01:01:11] Joe: You actually not only support kids financially, you have a dinner where they then begin to support each other. Talk about that a little bit.
[01:01:21] Tim: Yeah. So for the last 14 years, I’ve had a, a dinner on the third Thursday of October. It’s always the same place, the Minneapolis Club in downtown Minneapolis. It’s an opportunity for me to bring the students together.
[01:01:33] Tim: So if we step back and we say, okay, a new student finds out in August, early September, that they got the scholarship. They send their obligatory thank you email or, or, or note. All of a sudden, I reach out and I say, “Hey, congratulations. Welcome to the scholars. Would love to find time to set up a, a, a Zoom or a, a coffee just to get to know you better.”
[01:01:52] Tim: We have a chance to sit down and, and talk, and I say, “Hey, now I’m gonna invite you to this dinner.” And all of the past recipients are invited back. We usually have 15, 20, uh, students that come for that. And you get to ask them questions. They’re a season or two ahead of you. You get to ask them, “What do you think about, uh, different classes?
[01:02:09] Tim: How should I think about internships? What should I look at for that first job?” And they go and they get a chance to interact with others. My only ask of them is then next year I’m gonna have some new students that come, and you get to go and do it for them. If I fast-forward and see the transformation that they have over that four-year period, it’s amazing to see the confidence, the excitement that builds, and the friendships that build between them.
[01:02:32] Tim: And I’ve had many that over the years have said, “The financial pieces, that was really helpful, but the community and the sense of having someone who just wanted me to be successful, that meant so much more.” And so many students talk about their friends who also get scholarships that they’ve never had a chance to meet the donor.
[01:02:51] Tim: So my encouragement is is if you’re gonna do a scholarship, if you’re doing, gonna take the time, also take the time to meet the students, to connect with them and help build connections for them, open doors. It’s amazing how much more rewarding it was than I ever thought it would be.
[01:03:04] Joe: But I think we can even widen that out.
[01:03:06] Joe: If you’re not thinking about starting a scholarship, you’re just thinking about your community. You know, I, I help build walking trails around Texarkana. It’s one thing to give us a gift. It’s fantastic to give us a gift, but if you’re somebody, Tim, that knows how to do social media, man, do we need your help.
[01:03:24] Joe: The value of you being a part of the organization helps us so much more than a $100 gift does because we wanna get the word out in our community about how important these trails are. If you’re somebody who knows how to do fundraising or you’re somebody who knows engineering, you know something about construction of trails, urban planning, whatever it might be, I feel like there’s this middle ground of give money but also becoming a piece of this gives far more than dollars can give.
[01:03:54] Tim: Well, we all have so many different experiences that we can bring to a conversation. That’s why I’m a huge encouragement of young professionals getting involved on boards because you have a different perspective than a lot of the other board members, and collectively together you get so much more, and you can help that organization move forward in a much better direction You also get some great experience of having to think strategically much earlier in your career, which will help you in so many ways down the road.
[01:04:19] Joe: That intimidates people though, Tim. The second you said, you know, a young person getting on a board, I can imagine our stackers in their early 30s maybe, you know, in the middle of a middle-management career, right? Juggling all kinds of things in their life. And they’re like, “Get on a board?” H- how do they begin to think about getting on a board?
[01:04:39] Joe: How do they start that conversation?
[01:04:41] Tim: Well, the, the way you start is, is, uh, get involved with an organization that you love. Start volunteering. See how it runs, and then just keep an eye open and see maybe they need someone to serve on a committee. Maybe they need some board members. The first board you work to get on is gonna be hard, because you’re an unknown commodity.
[01:04:56] Tim: All of a sudden, as you deepen that conversation, you’ve asked more questions, you’ll get that first opportunity to get on board, and then you’ll get a second. The thing that I always caution people on is when that first board comes up after you’ve been on a couple boards, you, you have that person that reaches out and say, “Oh, we’d love to have you on this board,” your immediate reaction is is, “Oh, finally someone wants me on the board.”
[01:05:15] Tim: 95% of the time you should say no to that. Because you’re saying yes because someone’s finally asking you. They’re asking not necessarily knowing exactly what they need in a board member, so it might not be the right fit. So you always wanna evaluate to say, “Is this something I have a passion for? Am I gonna be excited about going to the meetings?
[01:05:33] Tim: Do I have something that, that I can help this organization out with?” And it’s that first one that, that comes out of the blue that you haven’t been looking for, that they ask you to be on the board, that you should pause and just say, “Oh, is this really still the best fit for me?”
[01:05:48] Joe: Tim, let’s go into one other area.
[01:05:50] Joe: You know, we talked to Adam earlier about donor-advised funds, but you work your charitable giving in a little different way. Let’s talk about this, ’cause we wanna give our Stackers as many different options as we possibly can today when they talk about giving. How do you go about this differently than a donor-advised fund?
[01:06:06] Tim: Well, I do a donor-advised fund, but I do a donor-advised fund through a, a local community foundation, and that local community foundation really has the heart and soul of what’s going on in there so that they know so much about what’s going on. They can be a convener that brings people together to talk about the issues that need to, to go on.
[01:06:23] Tim: So one of the boards that I serve on today is the Mankato Area Foundation. I’m currently vice chair there. Have had a about 15-year relationship with them. It’s so much more than just the transactional piece, uh, that is the donor-advised fund. It also is the, them bringing forward ideas for me. So some of the things that I’ve given to, I never would’ve had on my radar if they hadn’t gotten to know me and gotten to know, hey, you know, Tim really enjoys this area and really wants to make a difference in here.
[01:06:50] Tim: So they bring forward those ideas, and that has been so rewarding and has gotten me connected to organizations I never would’ve found out about in the past.
[01:06:59] Joe: So you’ve made it clear, though, in your head that you wanna give in the Mankato area specifically before you make that move.
[01:07:07] Tim: Mankato or the southern Minnesota area.
[01:07:09] Joe: The southern Minnesota area. That’s interesting, because before we even hit record today, you were talking about more on the daffy side with your, uh, with your godchildren about when they were young, giving to all kinds of different organizations just to get the process started.
[01:07:26] Tim: Yeah. So one of the neatest things I, I did is, um, many years ago when my godchildren were, uh, two and four years old, we set up a donor-advised fund for them, myself and their parents, and every year we say, “Hey, you can give $1,000 to whatever organization that you want to.”
[01:07:41] Tim: So then the two of them have to come together and talk about what is it that they care about, and it’s been just remarkable to watch them grow over the years from when they were two and four to now they’re 15 and 13, and they’re still every year finding an opportunity to give in a different organization.
[01:07:56] Joe: That is so cool. To watch it change over time, too, as they’re passionate about different things is a really great introduction to helping other people is helping yourself. Oh, gee, where’s the place you think we start?
[01:08:09] OG: Oh, well, I’m not sure that I’m qualified to have an opinion about that. But, um, I would say that you start with the things that you’re already doing and see if there’s a way to expand your reach in that area.
[01:08:22] OG: I’ve been waiting to try to figure out a way to put this story in there, and maybe I’ve talked about it before. But a couple years ago, Liz and I had always given some money to our school, you know, because we like what they do there, and it’s always been centered around a specific project, you know, something that we felt needed to happen.
[01:08:38] OG: And a year ago, or over a year ago now, the, uh, giving person there said, “Hey, you know, we’d like to go out to dinner,” and you know what they’re doing, right? Like, it’s like- … go out to dinner and, you know, “By the way, if you’re not, it’s not too much trouble, bring your checkbook,” you know? And so we had talked about it, and we came up with this plan.
[01:08:53] OG: We have cash flow, but we don’t have a lot of lump sum assets. You know, and some people have lump sum assets that they can give, and we’re more of a kind of a cash flow type of family. Liz and I talked about it, and we presented this idea to the, to the, uh, giving person, and she was like, “That’s fantastic.”
[01:09:08] OG: So I went to my coaching group, Strategic Coach, Joe, like, uh, as you know, and I was kind of puffing my chest out a little bit, right? Like a little bit of, “Look what I’ve decided to do,” and pretty proud of how we put this together. And a, a friend of mine in the group goes, “Yeah, I don’t think that’s enough. I think you should double that.”
[01:09:24] OG: And I thought, “What are you talking about? Like, this is a really big thing to me.” And he said, “Yeah, but just tell… Like, the worst that happens is you say, ‘I can’t do it.’ You know? Like, who cares, right? It’s, just try it out and see what happens.” And so I came back and, listen, I talked about it. We did this. Of course, you make this gift.
[01:09:41] OG: The giving person at the school is like, “This is fantastic, so very much thank you.” And a quarter later we do the same thing, and now she’s totally confused. And I said, “Oh, we’re gonna do this every quarter.” You know, the cascade of things that happened because of that, you know, like she hadn’t planned on it.
[01:09:55] OG: We didn’t plan on it. We did it, and now we’ve done it for basically seven consecutive quarters. But for me, two things were important there. One was a little bit of pushback from a friend that was like, “I think you can do more.” You know, and some of it of a little challenge, right? A little bit of like, okay, if, you know, if Joe says I can do more, maybe I c- I can’t let him down.
[01:10:17] OG: You know, so there’s a little bit of that. And then the other thing that’s been really interesting, and uh, causal or correlation, I don’t know. But you know, when I look back at how things were in our life a year and a half ago, and I look at how they are today, everything’s better. And I don’t know if that’s because of the giving or in spite of it, you know?
[01:10:36] OG: No. But it’s just like, it’s like the more… I just feel very strongly that the more that you invest in other people, whether that’s literally investing in them or literally giving money to them or something, more stuff and more benefits show up in your own life. It’s just a weird thing, you know, and we’ve talked about it on the show for years.
[01:10:55] OG: You know, it’s like if you can’t give away 1,000 bucks when you make 100,000, you’re never gonna give away 10,000 if you make a million. You have to build that discipline and that, that muscle, and some of it’s just a leap of faith, and you just go, “I’m just gonna do this because I’m, I’m good. I don’t need any more right now, and I can benefit these other people or these other places.”
[01:11:14] OG: And then all of a sudden you wake up one day and you go, “Well, now I have more.” You know? Yeah. It’s just this wonderful self-fulfilling prophecy of, you know, I give more and I get more to give more, and it’s just really quite awesome to see.
[01:11:25] Joe: I think Doug in his open said you don’t get much without giving, and it just- Yeah
[01:11:28] Joe: gives so much. And riding around, uh, Tim showing me around Mankato- And just watching him glow as he’s talking about the community and all the cool stuff going on because he’s involved fired me up. Like, I’m like, I th- you thought I was fired up, OG, about Texarkana. Like, I-
[01:11:45] OG: You got a sister city?
[01:11:46] Joe: I got a
[01:11:46] OG: sister city.
[01:11:46] OG: You got a little sign out front that says, you know, “Our sister city is Mankato.”
[01:11:49] Joe: Yeah, that’s right. Yeah. Welcome
[01:11:50] Tim: back anytime.
[01:11:53] Joe: Well, Tim, thanks a ton for joining us today and for sharing your expertise. We can, as stackers, we can stack more life for a lot more people around us, which also, to OG’s point, I think gives us a lot more life.
[01:12:05] Joe: Let’s go out on the back porch, Doug, and talk about what’s going on there.
[01:12:09] Doug: I would love to hear more from Tim about all the great things going on at the Southern Minnesota BAD Group and just how bad they are.
[01:12:18] Joe: Talk about giving. Tim and our good friend Rob help form this beautiful group on the university campus.
[01:12:25] Joe: Tim, what’s coming up?
[01:12:26] Tim: Well, we’ve had an amazing time this year. So we started out in January. We’ve had a, a, a meeting every month. We even had a chance to host, uh, Joe in there, but it’s been wonderful. We’re pulling in people from, uh, two m- uh- And I didn’t
[01:12:37] Doug: wreck it, just so everybody
[01:12:39] Tim: knows …
[01:12:39] Doug: not at all I didn’t wreck it.
[01:12:41] Doug: Attendance a little low that night, Tim?
[01:12:43] Tim: It, it, it was one of our higher attended one. Normally, we run anywhere between 15 and 30 people, and we were right at 30. We kicked off in January, and we had people coming down from the Twin Cities, from Rochester, from Marshall, so really coming from about two hours away into this location.
[01:12:58] Joe: Yeah, if you wanna fly in from Florida, stackers, or- Right … from San Diego, you know, until you get your own group, come visit southern Minnesota. It’s beautiful this time of year.
[01:13:06] Tim: It is wonderful this time of year. All the leaves are changing, and, uh, now we’re getting ready for our holiday event, so in early December we’re gonna have one.
[01:13:14] Tim: Other than that, we’re always on the fourth Wednesday of the month, and at Maverick Innovation Gateway here on the campus of Minnesota State University, Mankato.
[01:13:22] Doug: They get 30 people at the Maverick Innovation Gateway, which I presume does not have a liquor license. Imagine what would happen if you were at a bar.
[01:13:30] Doug: You’d have 100 people down there.
[01:13:33] Joe: The good news is we did find out that within walking distance there was beer after the meeting. Ah, okay. All right. Amen. We, we did find that out. Yeah, Tim and Rob and I and a few other great Stackers. Uh, we have this homing device where we were able to, able to find it. So yeah, whether you’re in Southern Minnesota or anywhere around the nation, look for them where you are at, uh, stackingbenjamins.com/bad.
[01:13:55] Joe: All right, thank you so much to Tim and Adam. What a great, great episode we were able to make today, and I hope, you know, don’t just go, “Oh, yeah, that was cool,” and then live tomorrow the way you lived yesterday. Let’s make a difference in our community, Stackers. I would love to hear what you’re doing. Write to me, joe@stackingbenjamins.com, or join us in The Basement Facebook group.
[01:14:16] Joe: But let’s encourage each other. Let’s do… Let’s be like that friend of OG’s and say, “You know what? I think you could do more,” to each other. I think that’s pretty, pretty cool. All right, we’re gonna end this episode the way we end every one. Doug, what should we have learned on today’s show?
[01:14:31] Doug: Well, Joe, first, take some advice from both Adam and Tim.
[01:14:35] Doug: Gifting isn’t about just giving away your money. It’s about being part of something bigger than you and contributing. Doing this well turns a yearly duty into something really fun and inspiring. Second, as Tim explained, begin with your goals and work backwards. If you don’t have goals, dive into an organization and get moving.
[01:14:55] Doug: Your feet will help your brain catch up. But my big lesson from today’s show, don’t tell Joe’s mom that on today’s episode you’re covering charitable causes. She’ll immediately infer that helping her can green beans is the best charity anyone can partake in if we know what’s good for us. Guess what I’m doing the rest of the day Thanks to Adam Nash for joining us today.
[01:15:19] Doug: You’ll find more about Daffy at his website daffy.org. That’s Daffy like the duck. We’ll also include links in our show notes at stackingbenjamins.com. Thanks also to Tim Hippech for joining us, or should I say Tim Hip hip hip hip Hippech?
[01:15:36] Joe: There it is.
[01:15:37] Doug: Wanna hang out with Tim and other cool Stackers? Come join them at a Southern Minnesota meetup sometime.
[01:15:43] Doug: You’ll find information on all of our Benjamins After Dark groups, including Tim’s Southern Minnesota group, at stackingbenjamins.com/bad. This show is the property of SB Podcast, LLC, copyright 2026, and is created by Joe Saul-Sehy. You’ll find out about our awesome team at stackingbenjamins.com, along with the show notes and how you can find us on YouTube and all the usual social media spots.
[01:16:11] Doug: Come say hello. And oh yeah, before I go, not only should you not take advice from these nerds, don’t take advice from people you don’t know. This show is for entertainment purposes only. Before making any financial decisions, speak with a real financial advisor. I’m Joe’s mom’s neighbor, Doug, and we’ll see you next time back here at the Stacking Benjamins show
[01:17:26] Joe: Welcome to the after show. This is the part of the show that doesn’t exist. What happens in the after show, Stacker, stays. And we, we stopped recording and, and Tim, you were talking about some of the, quote-unquote, gifts that you’ve, uh, received through the charitable foundation.
[01:17:44] Tim: One of the amazing things of a local community foundation is they can do more with non-cash assets.
[01:17:48] Tim: So you might think, “Hey, how do I give this away?” So some of our more interesting ones is we’ve been given an excavator, uh, which turned out to be perfect timing during COVID, that it was able to, uh, be sold almost immediately. Wow. Giving a load of grain, as opposed to, um, cashing it in, then giving cash. Uh, other- What do
[01:18:07] Joe: you do with the grain though, Tim?
[01:18:09] Tim: You sell it right away, then you turn it into the donor-advised fund, the dollars. Okay. But you don’t have to pick it up from an income perspective the same way. Gotcha. So there’s the, the tax people will, they’ll tell you a lot of details on that. Another interesting one is someone gave a, a historic sleigh, like a Santa Claus sleigh.
[01:18:26] Tim: Uh, that was a, was amazing. So you get all different types of them, including a, a herd of cattle that was given. So that’s the thing that a, a community, a local community foundation can do. They can work on those non-cash assets a little bit different. We also do a lot of real estate in that, but there’s a lot of different options out there.
[01:18:43] Joe: Oh, gee, you gonna give some of those little, uh, used pool noodles to a foundation maybe?
[01:18:49] OG: I was, I was just on the herd of cattle. I think you piece that out, you’ve- Hmm. You know, I’ve seen how much brisket costs at the, uh- Yeah … brisket place at 32 bucks a pound or 35 bucks a pound cooked. It’s like, you know, this is just, you could have, open a barbecue restaurant with a herd of cattle and…
[01:19:05] OG: I mean, I guess you have to know a thing or two about herding cattle, I suppose, first. But I know how to eat cattle. That’s what I’m really good at.
[01:19:13] Joe: Yeah, there’s both ends of the equation. There’s creating it- Yeah … and then there’s the other side, and we’re, we’re experts at the second half.
[01:19:19] Tim: Yes. It keeps our team, uh, the foundation, on their toes when they come up with these new, different ways of, of gifts.
[01:19:25] Tim: But that’s the ability that, uh, a, a local community foundation can really shine at.
[01:19:29] OG: Yeah, Schwab doesn’t really respond well to- They don’t … “How do I ACAT over my herd of cattle?”
[01:19:35] Joe: I can see Adam and his team at Daffy shows up for work on a Monday and here’s-
[01:19:40] OG: There’s just like a trailer out front …
[01:19:42] Joe: 25 head.
[01:19:43] Joe: It’s
[01:19:43] OG: for
[01:19:46] Joe: you.


Leave a Reply